13 thoughts on “NYU’s Economics Department Ranked Seventh in the World

  1. It’s hard for me to take seriously any ranking that includes George Washington University but not George Mason.

  2. I can’t take these rankings seriously either. Northwestern is #17 behind Warwick and Yale is #30.

  3. My degree grows more prestigious with each passing year without my having to do anything at all. Now THAT’S the causal efficacy of time for you!

  4. 1- No Brazilian universities in this ranking?

    2- It is possible that there are distortions on this raking, I mean, small american colleges are better than any university in japan?

  5. I’m guessing most readers are already aware of the very helpful (if somewhat outdated) econphd.net, with weightings that attempt to address some of the bias issues, as well as sub-specialty rankings.

  6. This list is not a ranking in the sense of Shanghai’s World Universities ranking. It is only a ranking according to the use of ideas/ repec. It features the registered authors/universities and the citations of works uploaded to repec. If this is the result, there is nothing to complain about. Maybe Japanese universities do not use ideas/repec as much as American and British universities.

  7. Congratulations!

    All rankings are somewhat suspect, but do give some sort of rough information. Being in the top X gives you some sort of reflection of reality. I doubt (hope?) most people take rankings as being either precise or accurate, but see them instead as useful despite clear limitations, and a fun jumping off point for discussion.

    I take the placing in the top 10 as meaning that NYU Economics Department is very solid, and if you can find a person in the department that matches your interests and can connect with you and mentor you, then you would be in very good company. Your resume would also emit an effervescent sparkle that would catch the eye of “ranking- and list-fetish world” dwellers.

  8. Damn no george mason? What is the standard of evaluation for being a top university? Articles published? Influential books? Nobels?

  9. Other than Econph.net, this is actually the only ranking I’ve seen that has Harvard, PU, MIT, U of C, and Cal at 1-5. In terms of reputation, this seems to be a no-brainer, yet some rankings punish U of C for having some faculty at the Booth School.
    It also seems to reaffirm things I’ve heard about up and coming departments (WUSL, several UC schools) and those that, well, aren’t so much (Cornell, Notre Dame).
    Regarnding George Mason, wouldn’t its emphasis on Austrian School economics make it kind of an outlier, and this sort of ranking useless in evaluating it? I don’t see it as a slight.
    My opinions are probably skewed because of Boston’s high ranking, though.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s